Excalibur...Innocent? / Rating Tracker Idea

I saw this posted on one of my buddies creations.

ExcaIibur commented:Mon Aug 30, 2010[report]
If you feel the need to satisfy some old vengance, then go ahead. I'm done with this. You should be too. Let's move on and drop this event behind us.
ExcaIibur commented:Mon Aug 30, 2010[report]
Even you come to me accusing me of downrating you. I don't even know you. I don't downrate and finally I don't care anymore.
ExcaIibur commented:Mon Aug 30, 2010[report]
At this point, I don't care who you are or aren't, I'm just tired of being harrassed by everyone and accused of everything.

It seems someone else is using Excalibur/LOM as a scapegoat for their own downratings. Sure, she may have done terrible things in the past, but now she seems to be mature enough to let down this farce. It's Sharpie63's story all over again, and i'm happy for this.

Because of this, what we need is a rating tracker. if someone rates your creations, they can appear on a list, one for uprating,one for downrating. if you are being mass downrated by a cyberbully with tons of alts, you can check the downrate list for your creation, and see WHO is doing the downrating. That way you can report them and their alts and get all downraters off of Spore. I think this feature would be very effective in stopping all this nonsense many creators are going through.

Thank you for your time.

where is this list?

camelfox wrote:

where is this list?

on Justuning's Orb Dragon.

oh

Hmm... this sounds like a good idea, but people shouldn't be so obsessed with cyberbullies and ratings. Things like this are fuel for bullies.

she might be being blamed, but read the comments on this:

http://www.spore.com/sporepedia#qry=advasrch-terrence%20the%20turtle%3Afi-name%2Cauthor%2Ctags%2Cdescription%3Afu-CREATURE%2CTRIBE_CREATURE%2CCIV_CREATURE%2CSPACE_CREATURE%2CADVENTURE_CREATURE%2CCITY_HALL%2CHOUSE%2CINDUSTRY%2CENTERTAINMENT%2CUFO%2CADV_ATTACK%2CADV_COLLECT%2CADV_DEFEND%2CADV_EXPLORE%2CADV_UNSET%2CADV_PUZZLE%2CADV_QUEST%2CADV_SOCIALIZE%2CADV_STORY%2CADV_TEMPLATE%3Am-LAND%2CAIR%2CWATER%3Ap-MILITARY%2CECONOMIC%2CCULTURAL%2CCOLONY%3Afl-MOST_POPULAR

sorry for the huge link, just click on terrence the turtle

Dark_Heroics wrote:

she might be being blamed, but read the comments on this:
sorry for the huge link, just click on terrence the turtle

... ok, THAT may be something unforgivable. but remember, that was in Febuary, when Exalibur joined on January, was still a troll, and had that War against Dizzybiz. like i said in the OP, she's done some terrible things in the past, but now she's being mature and apologizing to all whom she wronged, much like what Sharpie63 did back in 2009.

So...
Does this mean she's being blamed? or is she actually making alt accounts?

yes, she's being blamed, and in the past, sh'e made alts.

I'm not saying she's doing all the downrating NOW but... that's some harsh stuff

Excalibur..

That brings back some memories.

Anyway, Excalibur may be innocent, but still, there is something fatal about her story.
it feels like she tried to cover up her tracks..

No. Excalibur is guilty. I have absolutely no doubt.

I don't wish to give an opinion about ExacaIibur, or any Spore related drama, but something like rate tracking does seem like a good idea. If people couldn't rate anonymously I bet it would definitely cut back on the mass rating, whether they were rating something up or down.

I'm personally a believer in the tallying system. you give it a score out of five, and it only goes up. the 5 smile rating I think?

Dark_Heroics wrote:

I'm personally a believer in the tallying system. you give it a score out of five, and it only goes up. the 5 smile rating I think?

Also a cool idea.

You know what the really sad thing is about this whole "Excalibur vs. the spore community" thing? I made a gift for excalibur abouts a day before it started. Dirtymeat made a creaton against excalibur that was on the 1st page of the MPN. However, it had a red face. I asked him about how it could be on the MPN and he kindly replied. However, my gift was my most recent creation at the time. A day later, Excalibur saw the gift... and replied saying that I "carlessly let" Dritymeat ruin his gift. Darn right was I offended.

I also think a tallying system is a great idea!

Dark_Heroics wrote:

she might be being blamed, but read the comments on this:

http://www.spore.com/sporepedia#qry=advasrch-terrence%20the%20turtle%3Afi-name%2Cauthor%2Ctags%2Cdescription%3Afu-CREATURE%2CTRIBE_CREATURE%2CCIV_CREATURE%2CSPACE_CREATURE%2CADVENTURE_CREATURE%2CCITY_HALL%2CHOUSE%2CINDUSTRY%2CENTERTAINMENT%2CUFO%2CADV_ATTACK%2CADV_COLLECT%2CADV_DEFEND%2CADV_EXPLORE%2CADV_UNSET%2CADV_PUZZLE%2CADV_QUEST%2CADV_SOCIALIZE%2CADV_STORY%2CADV_TEMPLATE%3Am-LAND%2CAIR%2CWATER%3Ap-MILITARY%2CECONOMIC%2CCULTURAL%2CCOLONY%3Afl-MOST_POPULAR

sorry for the huge link, just click on terrence the turtle

O_____o
Well then, There's someone I'm going to consider removing from my friends list.....
I wanna know how long he's been doing that.....

too bad, huh? she IS a good creator...

You could do this http://www.spore.com/sporepedia#qry=advasrch-terrence%20the%20turtle But anyways I don't trust Excalibur and I don't want to get anywhere near her.

Saltdfrost wrote:

You could do this http://www.spore.com/sporepedia#qry=advasrch-terrence%20the%20turtle But anyways I don't trust Excalibur and I don't want to get anywhere near her.

Excalibur trusts me... I'm thinking of doing some 'detective work' if you know what I mean... Should I?

NOOOOOOO. don't get involved. is bad

Kitty wrote:

Saltdfrost wrote:

You could do this http://www.spore.com/sporepedia#qry=advasrch-terrence%20the%20turtle But anyways I don't trust Excalibur and I don't want to get anywhere near her.

Excalibur trusts me... I'm thinking of doing some 'detective work' if you know what I mean... Should I?

No. I investigate sometimes and I'm silent here's proof of Excalibur Confessing Click the first one http://www.spore.com/sporepedia#qry=advasrch-I%27VE%20HAD%20ENOUGH

Kitty wrote:

Saltdfrost wrote:

You could do this http://www.spore.com/sporepedia#qry=advasrch-terrence%20the%20turtle But anyways I don't trust Excalibur and I don't want to get anywhere near her.

Excalibur trusts me... I'm thinking of doing some 'detective work' if you know what I mean... Should I?

You defiently should! Just don't let anyone know! (i mean like Dirtymeat orr Excal or Slarti or any of those..)

I can help to..

GACModGlass wrote:

Kitty wrote:

Saltdfrost wrote:

You could do this http://www.spore.com/sporepedia#qry=advasrch-terrence%20the%20turtle But anyways I don't trust Excalibur and I don't want to get anywhere near her.

Excalibur trusts me... I'm thinking of doing some 'detective work' if you know what I mean... Should I?

You defiently should! Just don't let anyone know! (i mean like Dirtymeat orr Excal or Slarti or any of those..)

I can help to..

That's what I was thinking of doing. :P

I'm not sure if it's a good idea, though....
...Although, I am still a little peeved because of the gift I made him. :I

if you think about it this way:Excalibur doesn't want anyone to think she's a downrater, and i don't know if she is or not. But some mysterious things have happend.
She got on the MPN once, without supporters or anyone commenting on her creation.
Massuprating herself? Probably. How? Many alts.
There is a big chance that she is L0M but, We still cannot accuse her for that.
What about everyone just let this go. Slarti wants to protect the community, and yes, Excalibur has made some bad comments.
But Maybe we should all just ingore it because it doesn't seem as she's downrating anymore.
There are still some people out there being downrated like techno but.. What should we do about it?
Just let it go.. Justice does not always win.